Given the importance of quality education as part of the ECOWAS integration agenda, and the role which an institution such as the University of The Gambia (UTG) plays in this regard, the Centre for Community Law has been observing with keen interest developments at the UTG.
To this end, the Centre wishes to draw the attention of relevant Authorities to Protocol A/P3/1/03 on Education and Training, which recognises “education and training as an indispensable part of the mechanism for the realisation of the objectives of ECOWAS”.
The University of The Gambia (UTG) is at a critical crossroads following an escalating and bitter standoff between its Governing Council and the Vice-Chancellor, Professor Herbert Robinson. If unresolved transparently, the conflict could tarnish the institution’s reputation irreparably.
On 10 November 2026, the Standard newspaper carried a story titled “UTG’s Vice Chancellor’s Contract Not to Be Renewed”. Similarly, the following day, Foroyaa newspaper led with “UTG Governing Council Resolves Not to Renew Vice Chancellor Herbert Robinson’s Contract.” A second article by the same newspaper said “UTG Formally Notifies Herbert Robinson of Contract Non-Renewal, Demands Comprehensive Handover.”
The Foroyaa articles referenced a letter dated 2 November 2026 from the Chairperson of the Governing Council, Professor Momodou Mustapha Fanneh, addressed directly to Professor Robinson.
Under The Gambia’s Tertiary and Higher Education Act, 2016, only the President, as Chancellor of the university, has the power to appoint, renew or withhold renewal of an appointment. Legal experts therefore consider the Governing Council’s decision not to renew the appointment of the Vice Chancellor as ultra vires.
This article examines the facts and implications of the UTG Governing Council’s decision regarding renewal or non-renewal of Professor Robinson’s contract.
Professor Herbert Robinson was appointed as the 5th Vice-Chancellor of the University of The Gambia (UTG) on 30 November 2021 by the Chancellor of the University, President Adama Barrow. His appointment took effect in January 2022.
His appointment followed an open international call for applications, which attracted international and Gambian scholars. Robinson’s application emerged as the strongest among a highly competitive field of Gambian and international professors. He was subsequently offered a five-year contract, renewable subject to satisfactory performance.
At the time of his appointment, the Governing Council was chaired by Mr. Mathew Ndure, a respected educationist with extensive international experience. The Council also included several other distinguished members who have now left the service. During that period, the relationship between the Vice-Chancellor and the Governing Council was reportedly cordial, with both parties operating within their respective mandates and responsibilities.
However, the situation changed following the appointment of a new Chair and other members to the Governing Council, with reported tensions between the Council and the Vice-Chancellor.
In March 2026, the position of Vice-Chancellor was unexpectedly advertised, despite the fact that Professor Robinson still had more than nine months on his existing contract. He was neither informed of any decision not to renew his contract nor about an extension, as prescribed under the terms of his appointment.
According to an article published by The Standard newspaper on 2 March 2026, titled “President Sets Up Panel to Probe UTG Leadership,” the Ministry of Higher Education, Research, Science and Technology (MoHERST) instructed the Governing Council to proceed with the advertisement of the position of Vice Chancellor.The advertisement was reportedly welcomed by the President of the UTG Faculty and Staff Association, a member of the Governing Council, who, under the Tertiary and Higher Education ACT, 2016, is ineligible to serve as a Council member.
Having previously made statements critical of the Vice-Chancellor in the media, his reaction to the advert reported in the Foroyaa article of March 2026 titled “UTGFSA President Welcomes Advertisement of Vice-Chancellor Position as UTG, Seeks New Direction,” was unsurprising, but still raises questions about his credibility and impartiality in the UTG Vice-Chancellor’s case.
The decision to advertise the position before the completion of the contractual appraisal process was perceived by many, including Professor Robinson, as a violation of standard procedures and the terms of Professor Robinson’s contract. The result is an escalation of tensions between the Vice-Chancellor and the Governing Council.
President Barrow reportedly instructed that an independent Investigation Panel be established. Chaired by former Permanent Secretary of MoHERST, Yaya Sirreh Jallow, the Panel was tasked with examining the root causes of the leadership dispute at the UTG.. In carrying out its mandate, the Panel investigated the University’s governance structures and the sources of operational friction.
The Panel completed its work and submitted its report after nearly four months of investigation. To date, the report has not been made public. However, according to reliable sources, the Panel’s conclusions were unequivocal. It recommended the immediate removal of the Chair and Vice-Chair of the Governing Council, as well as the dissolution of the Governing Council, citing systemic governance failures.
The Panel also called for an objective assessment of the Vice-Chancellor’s performance by an independent body, the sources said.
A Cabinet Mediation Subcommittee was subsequently established on the Panel’s findings. However, according to the sources, the recommendations of the independent Panel have yet to be officially implemented.
Professor Robinson’s contract contains a clause providing for an extension, subject to a satisfactory performance appraisal. A contract is a legally binding agreement, and its provisions take precedence over general institutional rules. Consequently, the justification for advertising the position of the Vice-Chancellor, as reported in the Foroyaa article of 18 March 2026, citing Section 4.3.5 of the University’s Conditions of Service, appears unsustainable.
Also, a body that has been formally recommended for dissolution due to governance failures arguably lacks both the moral credibility and legal authority to evaluate the performance of the Vice Chancellor.
According to informed sources, Professor Robinson objected to being appraised by a Governing Council whose impartiality he considered compromised. Instead, he agreed to take part in an appraisal by an independent Panel.
Despite his objections, the Council proceeded with the appraisal, reportedly marred by procedural irregularities. For instance, the President of the UTG Faculty and Staff Association (UTGFSA), who is not a statutory member of the Governing Council, actively participated in the appraisal. His participation not only raised questions about the legality of the process but also contravened the confidentiality standards that should govern the assessment of a university’s principal officer.
The appraisal report has reportedly not been shared with Professor Robinson, raising further concerns about transparency and due process.
According to reliable sources, the call for applications for the position of Vice-Chancellor was, at one stage, placed on hold. It was later resumed, purportedly under a presidential directive. However, the legal basis for this directive was reportedly never provided to Professor Robinson, raising further questions about due process, transparency, and the legal basis for the decision.
Meanwhile, an investigation has revealed that the Chairperson of the Governing Council currently serves as the Vice-Chancellor of Euclid University, a private institution operating in direct commercial and academic competition with the UTG. Prior to his appointment, he unsuccessfully sought the position of Deputy Vice-Chancellor at UTG under Professor Robinson. This raises serious questions about the nature of the relationship and power dynamics between the two individuals, amid suspicion of personal grievances or perceived bias.
More importantly, can the Chair of the Governing Council be expected to act exclusively in UTG’s best interests in a situation where competing institutional interests are at stake, particularly regarding access to funding, strategic opportunities, resources, and confidential information?
The UTG is one of The Gambia’s most important institutions, entrusted with educating and shaping future generations of leaders, professionals, and public servants. As the nation’s premier public university, it should serve as a model of integrity, accountability, and good governance. Its credibility, reputation, and institutional independence must therefore be safeguarded at all times.
In the interest of fairness, transparency, and due process, the Government Subcommittee should move expeditiously to implement the recommendations of the Independent Investigation Panel. Professor Robinson should be afforded a fair and impartial appraisal conducted by an independent Panel, as recommended by the Investigation Panel.
The appraisal should also critically examine the operating environment during his tenure, including the over one hundred and twenty million Dalasis reportedly owed to the UTG by the MoHERST in unpaid student scholarship fees. (74 Dalassis-1USD).
If Professor Robinson’s appraisal confirms satisfactory performance, he should be allowed to continue implementing his vision and strategic agenda for the University, with the full support of the government and a competent, independent, and impartial Governing Council free from conflicts of interest.
Conversely, if the appraisal identifies significant shortcomings, he should be treated with respect, fairness, and dignity, and given his dues in recognition of his service to the University.
Ultimately, the resolution of this matter should be guided not by personal interests or institutional rivalries, but by the principles of justice, good governance, and the long-term interests of the University of The Gambia and the nation.
Ebrima Touray wrote from Banjul, The Gambia




